Jane Mayer: Thoughts on the Levin Report
President Obama has thrown a kind of protective, legal “invisibility cloak” over C.I.A. officers who may have participated in torture or other war crimes, but whose actions were authorized by lawyers in the Bush Administration. The reasoning goes that, if they were acting in good faith on the orders of superiors, it’s unfair to hold them to a different standard. But the unclassified report (pdf) from the Senate Armed Services Committee, released tonight by Chairman Carl Levin, raises questions about whether the C.I.A. was always operating with legal authorization.
Take. for instance, the torment of Al Qaeda suspect Abu Zubaydah, the guinea pig for the C.I.A.’s most abusive interrogation techniques, who was critically injured in a gunfight and captured on March 28, 2002. The Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel authorized harrowing tactics for interrogating Zubaydah in the infamous “Bybee Torture Memo” of August 1, 2002, which Obama released publicly last week. So, presumably, whatever happened to Zubaydah after August is indemnified by the Obama invisibility cloak. But what about what happened to Zubaydah in the four months before?
The Levin report provides some new details. On April 16, 2002—a couple weeks after Zubaydah’s capture, and three and a half months before the Bybee memo—a military psychologist named Dr. Bruce Jessen was already circulating a blueprint for cruelly coercive interrogations based on torture methods used by Chinese Communist forces during the Korean War. The report describes Jessen’s blueprint as a “draft exploitation plan” for U.S.-held captives. (I wrote about Dr. Jessen’s partner, James Mitchell, in the July 11, 2005, issue of The New Yorker.)
By June 2002—again, months before the Department of Justice gave the legal green light for interrogations—an F.B.I. special agent on the scene of the interrogation of Abu Zubaydah refused to participate in what he called “borderline torture,” according to a D.O.J. investigation cited in the Levin report. Soon after, F.B.I. Director Robert Mueller commanded his personnel to stay away from the C.I.A.’s coercive interrogations.
What did the F.B.I. see in the spring of 2002? And exactly who was involved? How high up was this activity authorized? Is it off-limits for criminal investigation?
There are plenty of new names and details in the Armed Services Committee report, including a scene of two military men teaching the C.I.A. how to use Chinese torture techniques. One of the instructors, Joseph Witsch, played the “beater,” while the other, Gary Percival, became the “beatee.” By the mid-summer of 2002, beating was no longer just an academic exercise. Precisely when these tactics were used on live captives, and at what point top Bush officials endorsed them, may be a matter of serious interest to Attorney General Eric Holder.
Wednesday, April 22, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
-
►
2018
(2)
- ► 03/25 - 04/01 (2)
-
►
2013
(5)
- ► 08/04 - 08/11 (2)
- ► 06/30 - 07/07 (1)
- ► 06/23 - 06/30 (2)
-
►
2012
(2)
- ► 08/05 - 08/12 (1)
- ► 06/03 - 06/10 (1)
-
►
2011
(3)
- ► 11/20 - 11/27 (1)
- ► 08/07 - 08/14 (1)
- ► 07/24 - 07/31 (1)
-
►
2010
(3)
- ► 11/21 - 11/28 (1)
- ► 11/07 - 11/14 (2)
-
▼
2009
(916)
- ► 06/14 - 06/21 (2)
- ► 06/07 - 06/14 (11)
- ► 05/17 - 05/24 (2)
- ► 05/03 - 05/10 (50)
- ► 04/26 - 05/03 (4)
-
▼
04/19 - 04/26
(90)
- PETER MAX
- ANNOTATED INAUGURAL SPEECH.
- JUST TOO STUPID
- Sun Tzu
- OBAMA NOT FUNNY AGAIN
- Inconvenient Truths By Christopher Hitchens
- Elizabeth: The Golden Age.
- FRENCH ECONOMIC STRIKE
- Gingrich: climate bill will punish Americans
- EARTH FROM ABOVE
- TYSON
- globalization, a synonym for Americanization,
- slate on torture
- Dershowitz: Torture could be justified
- Does torture work?
- PETER MAX
- Who Will Jesus Damn?
- Is Cheney Winning the Torture Debate?
- Robert J. Samuelson on the Great Depression
- links between memory and slumber.
- Can painful, unwanted memories be eradicated?
- PETER MAX
- Roper Public Affairs and Media poll
- The American left was mislead.
- GREAT GIFT OF FREEDOM
- DUMB THINGS PEOPLE ACTUALLY BELIEVE
- A CRAZED RANT ABOUT 3 D MOVIES
- I'LL BE SHORT by Robert B. Reich.
- COPYRIGHT
- WOODY ALLAN
- 'Losing Iraq'
- IN PRESIDENT '08
- Robert Bork
- Fulfilling Ronald Reagan's Vision for America
- THREE D. DON'T HOLD YOUR BREATH
- THREE D IGNORED AGAIN
- A QUALITY CRIME MOVIE
- $200 Laptops Break a Business Model NOW $479.60
- OLDER FILMS
- a sound body of law
- Reinhold Niebuhr
- I Lied About Making $80,000 Working From Home... A...
- THE DIGITAL DELIVERY OF EDUCATION
- OBAMA TO HARNESS THE WINDS
- David Baldacci
- the End of American Exceptionalism
- Deliverance
- RACISM IN AMERICA
- Susan Sontag
- DON’T LOOK NOW
- Border Betrayal: Ramos & Compean
- MYSTIC RIVER
- DEATH IN VENICE Luchino Visconti
- defining deviancy down.
- dumb apocalypse article
- black men and women wielding power
- THREE D STILL NOT TAKEN SERIOUSLY
- Brain differences mark those with depression risk
- “Life Without Lawyers”;
- STATE OF PLAY REVIEW
- torture or other war crimes
- NEW YORKER CARTOONS
- AMERICAN CARS AND UNIONS
- DEPRESSIONS OF THE NINETEENTH CENTURY
- manhunter
- THE SILENCE OF THE LAMBS
- JFK SCRIPT
- THE SILENCE OF THE LAMBS
- Gladiator
- THE DEVIL'S ADVOCATE
- DEAD MAN
- MASTER AND COMMANDER REVIEWS
- ENEMY AT THE GATES
- TWELVE MONKEYS
- THE SILENCE OF THE LAMBS
- JFK
- THE CONVERSATION
- KING OF NEW YORK
- MARATHON MAN
- A BEAUTIFUL MIND
- COMPTON CRIME WAVE ABATES
- THE USUAL SUSPECTS
- THE GODFATHER SCRIPT
- GANGS OF NEW YORK
- DOOM SAYERS
- “neuroenhancing” drugs
- MISCELLANEOUS IMAGES
- ILLUMINATED MANUSCRIPTS
- MEDIEVAL ART
- ANKHOR WATT
- ► 04/12 - 04/19 (32)
- ► 04/05 - 04/12 (15)
- ► 03/29 - 04/05 (160)
- ► 03/22 - 03/29 (107)
- ► 03/15 - 03/22 (124)
- ► 03/08 - 03/15 (37)
- ► 03/01 - 03/08 (19)
- ► 02/22 - 03/01 (7)
- ► 02/15 - 02/22 (256)
No comments:
Post a Comment